Harrison Armstrong contract is Everton’s biggest job now


Everton fought off Nottingham Forest for Harrison Armstrong in the summer, but the job is only half done. Until the 19-year-old signs a new contract, the Forest saga hasn’t really gone away.

Armstrong’s current deal, signed in January 2025, runs until June 2028. That sounds like plenty of time. It isn’t, not for an academy midfielder who has started every week under David Moyes and is already in the England U21 picture, and not at a club whose owners put it up for sale in October.

The international break has given Everton a rare quiet fortnight before Monday night’s trip to Brentford. If we were sitting in the boardroom, this is the deal we would be getting done with that time.

Why is the Harrison Armstrong contract so urgent?

Because the summer showed exactly what other clubs think he is worth. Nottingham Forest made a reported £40m approach in late August, and Moyes could only confirm it. “There’s been an offer. Apart from that, I don’t think there’s much else I can say, it’s a club decision,” he said at the time.

The away game at Bournemouth was meant to be his farewell. He played 87 minutes of the 1-1 draw that James Tarkowski rescued late on, the travelling fans made their feelings plain, and Everton’s owners pulled the plug on the sale. It was the right call, and it was made because supporters forced the issue.

The problem is what Forest left behind. Reports at the time suggested the personal terms on the table were far bigger than anything Armstrong earns at Everton, and a player doesn’t forget being shown that number. If the gap stays that wide, his agents will know there’s a queue of clubs who would happily close it.

A teenager who has been a seven out of ten every week

What makes this so frustrating is how well Armstrong handled all of it. He didn’t say a word in public, he didn’t sulk, and he simply kept playing. Moyes is not a manager who hands young players a shirt for the sake of it, yet Armstrong started on the opening day and has been a regular ever since.

He has earned it. Loan spells at Derby County and Preston North End gave him proper men’s football rather than five minutes off the bench, and it shows. He reads the game well, carries the ball forward with real pace and gets back to help the centre-backs when the side needs it.

Every squad needs a midfielder who turns up with a solid performance every single week, and that is what he has been. If there’s one thing missing, it is goals. He doesn’t score enough yet, but that is a detail for a box-to-box player who doesn’t turn 20 until January.

Where does he fit next to Garner and Dewsbury-Hall?

Right in the middle of the one part of the squad that actually works. James Garner is getting back towards his best, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall is the technical link between midfield and attack, and Armstrong gives the side legs and balance alongside them. His captain has already called Dewsbury-Hall an England-level midfielder, and that pairing is a big reason Everton went into the break sixth.

It also explains why Hayden Hackney, the Championship’s player of the season with Middlesbrough, is still waiting for regular starts. Plenty of Evertonians want to see more of Hackney, and so do we, but that is a compliment to Armstrong rather than a knock on the new man. Midfield is the one area where Moyes has real competition for places, and Armstrong is winning it.

The ownership sale makes it riskier

The Friedkin Group put Everton up for sale on 9 October, barely two years after buying the club. Nobody knows who will own Everton by next summer, or what they will want from the squad.

That is the real danger. A young, cheap, homegrown midfielder with under two years left on his deal is exactly the kind of asset that gets sold to balance the books during a takeover. Tie him down now, on a long contract at a fair wage, and he becomes a player any new owner builds around rather than one they cash in on.

According to Football Insider, Everton have been planning contract talks with Armstrong since October. There’s no sign he is unhappy, and nothing suggests the talks have hit trouble. There’s no new deal either, though, and every month that passes makes the next offer more expensive.

What should Everton offer?

Everton probably don’t want a teenager jumping straight to the top of their wage bill, and we understand why. A deal that rises in steps would solve that: a sensible starting salary that climbs as he hits appearance and performance targets. It rewards him for the season he is having, keeps him hungry and protects the club if his progress slows.

Europe matters too. If Everton finish high enough to qualify, keeping him gets much easier. If they don’t, he and his advisers will have a decision to make next summer, and Moyes’ own future may come into it as well.

Verdict: get the Harrison Armstrong deal done before January

Everton are on a good run. They beat Newcastle twice in four days, including the 1-0 win at St James’ Park, then came from behind to beat Coventry 3-1. Armstrong has been part of all of it, and he is part of what a new Everton should look like.

The fans saved him once. The club shouldn’t need them to do it again. Get the new contract signed before the January window opens, even if it means paying a bit more than the wage structure would like, because the alternative is another Forest-style bid in the summer and far less power to say no.



Source link