Man City 1-1 Fulham as Haaland goal is ruled out by VAR



Enzo Maresca says it was “quite clear” that Erling Haaland’s ruled-out goal should have stood, after Manchester City were held 1-1 by Fulham at the Etihad Stadium on Saturday.

Rodrigo Muniz gave the visitors a 16th-minute lead, Haaland thought he had equalised in the first half only for VAR to back the referee’s call of a foul on Bernd Leno, and Elliot Anderson’s volley just before the hour rescued a point.

It means City have now gone four Premier League games without a win, and the draw ends an English record run of 20 straight defeats for Fulham against them.

Why was Haaland’s goal disallowed?

Iliman Ndiaye whipped in a cross from the right and Haaland got to it a yard or so out, but his contact was soft and the ball went straight at Leno, who parried it with both hands. Haaland’s momentum carried him on, he touched the ball a second time while the German was still gathering it, and it rolled over the line.

Haaland wheeled away to celebrate, but referee Tom Bramall had already given a free-kick to Fulham, and the VAR check confirmed it. The Premier League Match Centre explained the decision afterwards: “The referee’s call of free-kick to Fulham and no goal to Manchester City was checked and confirmed by VAR, with the goalkeeper deemed to be in control of the ball.”

The VAR’s own explanation went further: “The ball is in control between both hands and then is played out of that possession by the attacker, and then into the back of the net.” Under the laws, a goalkeeper is in control when the ball is between his hands, or between his hand and any surface such as the ground or his own body.

Maresca: “I’m not the guy that decides”

The City boss watched the incident again after full-time and was not convinced. “I reviewed the goal after the game,” Maresca said. “From my point of view it’s quite clear that it’s not a foul but I’m not the guy that decides unfortunately.”

He also revealed what his striker told him while the check was going on. “He was absolutely sure, even when they were reviewing the VAR, that it was a goal because I asked from the touchline and he was completely sure, but again the referee decided for different reasons.”

Replays were hard to read. Leno looked to still be gathering the ball, and it is difficult to tell whether he had both hands on it at the moment Haaland made contact. The officials decided he did, and that was that.

Muniz and Bobb punish City again

Fulham’s goal came from a sweeping counter-attack. Former City winger Oscar Bobb raced down the right and picked out Rodrigo Muniz, who took one touch and bent a right-footed shot into the top corner past Gianluigi Donnarumma.

It was Muniz’s first Premier League start of the season, with Gonzalo Garcia dropping out to make room. Our Fulham predicted lineup vs Man City had Bobb and Shea Charles back at their old club.

Anderson’s volley saves a point

City’s equaliser came just before the hour. David Affengruber headed a corner clear, but only as far as Elliot Anderson, who met it first time with a right-footed volley into the bottom-left corner.

Anderson was City’s best player, driving the midfield all afternoon. At the other end Affengruber, the 25-year-old summer signing from Elche, made six clearances, six recoveries, three blocks and three tackles to keep Fulham in it. City had 60 per cent of the ball, and both sides had chances in a lively second half, but neither found a winner.

Where does Man City vs Fulham leave the title race?

Maresca won his first seven Premier League games in charge, which no manager had done before. Since then City have lost to Aston Villa, Brighton and Nottingham Forest, and this is their first league draw of the season. We wrote before the game that Fulham at the Etihad was the biggest test of Maresca’s reign, and his side did not pass it.

The defence is the worry. City have kept no clean sheet in their last seven home games and have conceded 18 goals in their last nine matches in all competitions. They are third, behind Brighton on goal difference, and six points behind leaders Arsenal after the Gunners drew 2-2 at Newcastle later on Saturday. Next up for City is a trip to Arsenal.

For Fulham, it is a third draw in a row and a fifth straight league game without defeat. Alvaro Arbeloa’s side are 14th, three points above the relegation zone, and nine of their 11 points have come in the last five gameweeks.

Verdict: City can’t keep blaming the officials

Maresca has a case on the Haaland goal, and plenty of neutrals will agree with him. But the officials did not let in Muniz’s goal, and it did not leave the defence open for the seventh home game running. With Arsenal away next, a point against a side that had lost 20 in a row to them feels like two dropped, and the gap at the top could be nine by the end of next weekend.



Source link